Reply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor activity Abbey (II) -...
by Hermjard Yes, this is indeed the notion, which made me suspicious: You cannot use the outdoor activity, when you "charge" a delayed-until-the-end-of-the-game effect with your action. But on the...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor Activity Military Camp (IV)...
by Hermjard Another hint for that you are right (apart from being overpowered) could be, that it would be unclear, how the vacant third rank should be assigned, when not a single, but two colors are...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor Activity Port (II) -...
by chris1nd For what it is worth, I believe Curt has it exactly right.Sometimes instead of parsing translations of rules, you have to think about what makes more game sense. I do not believe that the...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor Activity Port (II) -...
by louper Frank - Not to be rude, but it seems like with many of your rules questions, you get answers from the community but just don't want to accept their answers. In addition to this thread,...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor Activity Fort (III) -...
by curtcHermjard wrote:So, are you allowed to use the purple die, to fill cubes onto the Outdoor Activity to reroll the purple die, yes or no?The intent seems to be no, despite the language issues in...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor activity Abbey (II) -...
by curtc This is the one outdoor activity where the rules failed me. Here's what I think it means (by no means authoritative):When you activate a CARD (on the main board) which has delayed effects...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor activity Abbey (II) -...
by Hermjard I don't believe that, because it's simply not, what the text specifies. Nowhere is stated, that the single cube on another delayed (or mixed or end-of-game) activity is not additional but...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor Activity Port (II) -...
by Hermjard I accept the answers from the community, if they are logically derived from the existing, written rules. Or when they are derived from confirmed substance of the rules, how they were meant....
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor Activity Fort (III) -...
by Hermjard The problem with that is, if you are indeed forbidden to fill the purple die reroll outdoor activity with a point of the purple die, then from this directly follows, that you allowed to...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor activity Abbey (II) -...
by chris1nd Aren't the pargeer cubes used in the expansion for the outdoor activities?
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor Activity Port (II) -...
by curtcHermjard wrote:Clearly only certain activities can be played during event resolution. So the fact that the rules say activities can be used during other players' turns and during event...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor Activity Port (II) -...
by chris1nd Almost always when someone is arguing that if whatever most people agree is how the rule functions is wrong because "if that were the case why wouldn't the rule have been worded slightly...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor activity Abbey (II) -...
by louperchris1nd wrote:Aren't the larger cubes used in the expansion for the outdoor activities?Not necessarily - larger cubes merely represent three of the smaller cubes and can be used anywhere...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor activity Abbey (II) -...
by chris1nd Cool, missed that!
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor Activity Port (II) -...
by Hermjardcurtc wrote:Hermjard wrote:This makes no sense to me. So I don't believe, you are right.So you believe that all outdoor activities may be used when combating events? Please explain how that...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor Activity Port (II) -...
by chris1nd Why yes, yes I do.
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor Activity Port (II) -...
by Hermjardcurtc wrote:Hermjard wrote:Btw, assuming you are right, wouldn't it be more effective and more consistent, to say "Cubes on outdoor activities work exactly like cubes on cards with delayed...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor activity Abbey (II) -...
by curtcHermjard wrote:I don't believe that, because it's simply not, what the text specifies. Nowhere is stated, that the single cube on another delayed (or mixed or end-of-game) activity is not...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor Activity Port (II) -...
by curtc Well, I had trouble following your last couple posts, and rather than try to get into the details of it, since I think we're starting to go round and round, I'll just say that I think the crux...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor Activity Fort (III) -...
by curtcHermjard wrote:The problem with that is, if you are indeed forbidden to fill the purple die reroll outdoor activity with a point of the purple die, then from this directly follows, that you...
View Article