Reply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Catapult
by Bean-BoyAlain13 wrote:I don't have the english rules (but I suppose you've rewritten exactly the right terms)but in the french rules, it's clearly written that if only one space is available, you...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor Activity Port (II) -...
by Hermjard Hmm, let me ask a assume some things from your answer. You compared exchanging the dice with buying dice. I assume, that means:1) Dice, you got by exchange must be used in that action,...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Catapult
by chris1nd Variant forum? In none of your threads where you insulted the rules and the designers has anyone proposed a variant. Several of us tried to explain why we thought a certain ambiguity or...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor Activity Port (II) -...
by chris1nd Now, those are good questions!We assumed that once exchanged, they could be kept, bought, or manipulated as if "owned".In practice, "keeping" never really came up, but we probably have...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor Activity Port (II) -...
by curtcHermjard wrote:1) Dice, you got by exchange must be used in that action, directly after they were exchanged. They cannot be "stored". That is presumably also the reason for the limit of three...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Catapult
by curtcHermjard wrote:Well, so may it be. I already noticed, that this forum seems a little bit different than the rules forums for other games. Amoung the differences, that presented rule ambiguities...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor Activity Port (II) -...
by louper If the dice are NOT allowed to be saved for a future action, how do you note the dice that you give to other players (since it isn't their turn, they cannot use them immediately). If other...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor Activity Port (II) -...
by Hermjard Of course: This leads to the well known notion, that a board game has no "memory" or "history". That's the reason why I assumed (3). I am not so sure with (1) and (2) though.Pro (1) and...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Catapult
by Hermjard Getting opinions presented by people, who are overconvinced, from themselves is not a discussion.Like you, for example in the rules forum of Power Struggle:You know that the player who...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Catapult
by curtcHermjard wrote:Getting opinions presented by people, who are overconvinced, from themselves is not a discussion.Exactly, that's the problem here.Hermjard wrote:Like you, for example in the...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Catapult
by HermjardWe need not dilute the signal:noise ratio by prefacing every sentence with the painfully obvious "It is my opinion that...""We"? For whom do you speak? Did you get some sort of mandate? Or...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Catapult
by louperHermjard wrote:We need not dilute the signal:noise ratio by prefacing every sentence with the painfully obvious "It is my opinion that...""We"? For whom do you speak?Using "We" as Curt did is...
View ArticleThread: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Banker
by HermjardIf you have more than 30 deniers, you earn 3 VPs. You do not need to spend the money in order to earn the VPs.Notice the difference between the text and the symbols, which suggest the...
View ArticleThread: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Augustine
by Hermjard"In putting together a group of dice, you can use a cube from Augustine as if it were a yellow 6 from your own district of the city square. You can cannot use this cube alone; you must group...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Augustine
by louperHermjard wrote:"In putting together a group of dice, you can use a cube from Augustine as if it were a yellow 6 from your own district of the city square. You can cannot use this cube alone;...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Banker
by louperHermjard wrote:If you have more than 30 deniers, you earn 3 VPs. You do not need to spend the money in order to earn the VPs.Notice the difference between the text and the symbols, which...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Banker
by curtc Well, there is a bit of precedent for the game materials to be correct, and the rules to be incorrect. (Let alone errors in the rules without corresponding game components). For example the...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Augustine
by Hermjard Ah, the question "Why" again - for example, because it's part of a verbal deal between players, not to activate a certain card too often? I still don't know, what an allowed move has to do...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Banker
by loupercurtc wrote:Well, there is a bit of precedent for the game materials to be correct, and the rules to be incorrect. (Let alone errors in the rules without corresponding game components). For...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Augustine
by Bean-Boy The influence actions work on dice and the text of Augustine never makes the cube a die. It merely allows it to stand in as if it were a die.
View Article