Reply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Catapult
by HermjardWhat I still don't understand is why you just don't decide for yourself what works best and play that way.I am sure I never will.What I still don't understand is why you are still active in...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Catapult
by Hermjardfardoche wrote:Usually, in the boardgame hobby, if very specific and far-fetched cases (as in your 4 or 5 last posts in LoT) are not addressed in the rulebook, one should use common sense to...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Catapult
by chris1nd I subscribe to this game. I have played many times. I offer my interpretation or opinion when someone asks about a certain rule. I am trying to help folks.I do not claim to have infinite...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Catapult
by curtcHermjard wrote:What I still don't understand is why you are still active in this rule forum, when it's just your intention to decide or at least try out for yourself what works best and play...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Catapult
by Hermjard I don't know if you were ever on the forums about, for example LCGs? There are threads of dozens of postings, where it is discussed, where a comma in a single sentence is put. Don't believe...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Catapult
by Hermjardchris1nd wrote:I do believe that people who have (a) not written rules, (b) not designed games, and (c) not really even played the one in question, should suspend their hubris.What you know...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Uprising + Other Building-related...
by Hermjard No, I will not disagree. Because I know, that my interpretion is equally weak. "as if it had been expelled" can also mean, that this meeple was not expelled by shifting, but by mixing the...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Catapult
by chris1nd"it's not about written rules. It's about game experience.":whistle:
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor Activity Fort (III) -...
by Alain13Hermjard wrote:"Important notes: The die you use to place a cube on this activity, via Action 7 - Use your guard on the ramparts, must be of a different color than that of the die shown on...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor Activity Port (II) -...
by Alain13Hermjard wrote:"Discard a cube from this activity in order to exchange one die with each opponent, without changing their values. You can only make one such exchange with each opponent. It is...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor Activity Port (II) -...
by Hermjard Thank you for your determining.Answer 2 leaves open, at what times this outdoor activity can be used. I assume, before one of your actions... and? Perhaps before I fight a black die?I...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor Activity Fort (III) -...
by Hermjard Thank you for your determining.
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Catapult
by Hermjard If your refer to the recent decisions of the game author, I cannot notice any basical difference between yesterday and today. I have never denied the possibility, that the game author...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor Activity Port (II) -...
by Alain13Hermjard wrote:Thank you for your determining.Answer 2 leaves open, at what times this outdoor activity can be used. I assume, before one of your actions... and? Perhaps before I fight a...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Catapult
by chris1nd Nothing was proven by the big cube/little cube thing. I can use jelley beans on the outdoor acitvities and it will not affect game play. Shall I recount every rules proposition you have put...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Catapult
by Alain13Hermjard wrote:"You may:. place 1 cube on the card (load the catapult) OR. discard 1 cube from the card in order to place 2 cubes from your supply on a single Event card (fire the...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Outdoor Activity Military Camp (IV)...
by Alain13Hermjard wrote:"At the end of the game, the player who has placed the most cubes on this activity earns 8 VPs; second earns 4 VPs, and third earns 2 VPs. In the case of a tie, the tied...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Catapult
by Hermjardchris1nd wrote:Nothing was proven by the big cube/little cube thing. I can use jelley beans on the outdoor acitvities and it will not affect game play. Shall I recount every rules...
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Catapult
by curtcHermjard wrote:And I would always repeat my behavior under similar circumstances, because it earned me respect...Maybe from some people. It also lost you some from others.
View ArticleReply: The Ladies of Troyes:: Rules:: Re: Catapult
by Hermjard Well, so may it be. I already noticed, that this forum seems a little bit different than the rules forums for other games. Amoung the differences, that presented rule ambiguities are not...
View Article